Friday, March 11, 2011

What you need to do if you have 'Autogynephilia.'

This will be my last post. I feel that after five months of exhaustive self-inflection I can finally move on. Tackling what it meant to be an autogynephiliac/crossdreamer was essential for me to be able to do this, so I hope and pray that others may be able to do the same. I'm leaving this blog up in hopes that it will help guide people toward their own path.

This is a message for those that think they are suffering from gender dysphoria, but feel perplexed by autogynephilia. If you are 100% certain with your masculine identity, this message is not for you. Everyone else, enjoy.

What it means to have Autogynephilia or to Crossdream: It's a unique sexual fetish so strong that its probably definitive of your entire sexuality. If your arousal is driven solely on the thought of becoming or existing as a woman then you are a 'crossdreamer'. The typicalities of people living with this are somewhat uncanny: struggles with initiating sex with a partner, ongoing compulsive behavior, and depression are just some of what many have experienced. Crossdressing is common, but not necessary for crossdreamers.

Why you have it: This was the big question for me when I started researching this, and I became exceedingly frustrated that there was/is no scientific explanation. Even the best of explanations are met with so much resistance that its nearly impossible to decide how this pertains to you. So excuse me if this comes across as way too bold and wildly unscientific, but I understand the urgency you're probably feeling if you're trying to find the answer- so I'm just going to give you the explanation that provides me with satisfaction.

The reason you have autogynephilia is because you lack any other ability to express your femininity. It's the outlet that your "inner girl" uses to relieve pressure. You may then ask yourself, "Well Renee, then why don't all guys have autogynephilia? Don't all guys have a feminine side?" The answer to this is probably going to be hard to swallow, but: Not quite like you do. The fact is, that deep at your core you may desire to actually live as a woman.

In the past few months, I'm yet to speak to any crossdreamer that is entirely confident in their portreyed gender identity. I've asked many of them the same question: "If everything you knew and loved was destroyed in an earthquake tomorrow, would you pass up the opportunity to live as female if given the chance." (I might further explain that it would be as a natural, attractive female so they don't confuse the intent of the message with something like living as a transexual.) In every case the answer is yes.

What's interesting about this is that I don't initially ask that question. I first ask just a more simple question: "Do you identify as trans person or do you have any desire to actually become a woman?" The answer has mostly (but not always) been no. Further conversation yields commonality in their responses: "I wouldn't pass;" "My current world would be turned upside down;" "I have too many obligations;" "It's scary;" "Sex changes don't make you a 'real' woman;" and so on. Ultimately, what I learned is that many of us only live as men because of how impossible it feels to become women, even the ones that initially claim that the buck stops at AGP.

Bottom line here: Chances are you're transsexual. Note that when I say that, I don't mean that you should necessarily go forward and start taking hormones and get sex reassignment surgery. I'm just saying that you are compelled by the same thing that many others have acted on- having gone forward to become women.

What this means to you: That really depends. If the incongruence between how you live and how you desire to live is causing you to live in misery, then you need to go forward and pursue the life that you want. "Are you telling me that I should want to actually become a woman?" I asked this to numerous transexuals only to be met with vague answers like "Only you know what is right for you" or "I can't answer that for you." Well I personally don't like non-answers, so I'm going to give the straight dope:

The answer is Yes.

The only reason I feel confident in saying this because if you have made it this far in reading then you're probably having strong doubts about your gender identity. If however, you are just reading this for shits and grins then please disregard.

Now heres why.

Because you need to be happy, you deserve it, and you've denied yourself for too long. You can try finding your purpose in life for the rest of your years, but you'll only be miserable. If you reach down beyond the AGP to find that you're actually dysphoric, then this is going to be your only solution. And heres some more reasons why:

First, if you're a Christian then you need to read the following passages: Isaiah 56:4-5, Mattew 19:12, Acts 8:26-39, and Mark 9:46-47. For the record, eunuchs were castrated men. It didn't really have anything to do with them being trans, but castrated none the less.

But the point to take away here is that as a Christian, you aren't supposed to lie. You're supposed to live an honest life. Integrity. If you are feeling that you are at wits end in a Christian catch 22, I'd like you to consider those above passages in making your determination of how you want to represent yourself to God. Would you rather be honest as his creation by embracing your true self or would you rather suffer in Old Testament ideals that justify the Christian Right to frown upon your true nature? How would Jesus treat the young transwoman thats being rejected by her Church establishment? My idea: He embraces and loves her for everything she is.

The second reason I have is just general philosophy. We as humans seek happiness/pleasure. Depending on your school of thought, in any instance you are going to seek to maximize your overall happiness.

The problem is that when your living as the wrong gender, you're living against your natural virtues. And even if you don't believe that being virtuous is the ultimate way to achieve happiness, you can at least consider that its impossible to experience maximum fulfillment or pleasure as the opposite gender, unless you become the opposite gender. If your ultimate pinnacle form or self actualization is to exist as a Megan Fox lookalike, then why are you trying so hard to do anything but?

---------------------------------------

In the coming months its my intent to truly come out to my partner. While I'd like to say I'm optimistic about her reaction, I'm not. She already is aware of my AGP, and doesn't really want it in our lifestyle, so I doubt further progression will be taken well. It's unfortunate for me, but its not her fault. Unfortunately for her, I don't see myself as capable for providing this manufactured personality for much longer.

I'm soon to embark on a whole new world. And a whole new me.

I'd like to thank everyone that helped me piece this together. From the IRC's to Blogistan.

16 comments:

  1. Playing a shame-game gets you worn down. If living honestly means transition, then your bell has rung and it is time to ditch the "manufactured personality" and do what is right.

    When and if that happens to me, I will call it a personal choice, and won't argue with someone who tells me "only you can tell if you are transsexual". I will have just proved her point. :)

    Halle

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks for your article. It's very intersting and made me think about lot of things... Actually I have autogynophilia but I don't relly feel like "true woman" (like, for example trans-girls are feeling...), I feel more like, eh, just ordinary pervert... :(
    But I don't feel really like a man, I think about myself more like in between - but maybe I'm only cheating myself? I don't sure. Anyway, I usually like being pansy. :) But I'm not sure if I would feel good as a woman. I had rather typical childhood, not like trans-girls, I interested in astronomy, physics and science-fiction literature, etc.

    (sorry if my English isn't good, it isn't my first language)

    ReplyDelete
  3. I was interested in astronomy, physics and science-fiction literature before and after transitioning to become a woman.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Renee, thank you for this article. I have been trying to find out who I am for the longest time, and this was the final missing piece of the puzzle. The questions you asked others really helped me. My answers were different, and they helped me really determine that I am trans. Your straight "Yes" answer to whether I should go through with it if I feel like I should also really helped. Thank you so much!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Renee, that was a short but concise explanation on the difference between AGP and trans. It's not always easy to distinguish between the two since the similarities are vast and the differences slight. And these are also questions I have been pondering for myself. To yours I'd like to add one of my own. This has been instrumental in determining my own attitude (and courage) at deciding between AGP and TS.

    "You are at a couple of doors, one labeled 'HRT', the other 'SRS'. What are your thoughts about what's beyond either door?"

    Only the person before either door can answer the question.

    Also I wish the best of luck to you and your partner, either together or separately as the case may be. God speed and hangeth in there. My Yahoo address is on my blog if you wish to chat further.

    Sarah

    ReplyDelete
  6. Best wrap-up ever!

    As for you adding no more posts: I'd really love to see you post some more, as your writing gives me a lot. I also truly believe that there are more crossdreamers than me that would benefit from hearing about the next phase in your life.

    Still, the reason you give makes sense.In any case: thank you for writing this.

    I know I will see you over at Crossdream Life.

    ReplyDelete
  7. @xr9: You don't need to have a TS childhood to be TS. Also, what about Sci-Fi and physics is male only?

    @KyraMcAfrea: I'm glad it helped you. It's really good to hear.

    @Sarah Murphy: Believe it or not Sarah, I wasn't trying to draw a line or differentiate between AGP and Trans. You can definitely be both.

    @Jack Molay: Thanks. Yeah sorry, but thats going to be all for this blog. I will leave an announcement here for my transition blog when I get started.

    And for the love of God... When is CrossdreamLife going public? Make it known! I'm lonely over there...

    ReplyDelete
  8. @Renee
    "You don't need to have a TS childhood to be TS."
    As I supppose at this moment, AGP is symptom that can by caused by different things in psyche. I'm aware that other people can be different than me. I know good only my own case so I'll write about it: I never was sure about my gender identity, and until adulthood I never really thought that I must do something with this, ;) nevertheless I found many inconsistencies with my life and feelings and memories of TS people.

    "Also, what about Sci-Fi and physics is male only?"
    Ok, it's not when we look in objective way (probably it isn't typical interests for both genders :D), but they aren't perceived as typical interests for women? But it isn't only this, as child I normally played with other boys, etc.

    Some days ago I finally found that I'm person with AGP, after it I started reading crossdreaming blogs and thinking a lot (I'm very thankful to you for that). Now I'm thinking that it's fundamental difference between me and, for example, transwomen, even if it can look simillar in some way. I think I even should be more like typical man (I suppose that strong polarization to both genders would be little hard for me), without that maybe I won't be happy.

    So at this moment I would support that attitude "only you know what is right for you" - every person is different...

    ReplyDelete
  9. More shortly: I'm not transwoman, my propensity is just sexual.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Wow, what a post! I proclaim WIN...

    You are so right: many of us only live as men because of how impossible it feels to become women.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Very nicely said Renee. Thank you for this. :)

    ReplyDelete
  12. I mentioned this over on reddit, but I thought I'd add it here as well. I'm glad to see someone who self-identifies with autogynephilia because my only experience until now has been with those who would broadly apply it to all trans women. So, thank you for your perspective.

    You say this is your last post, but that you're planning to go forward from here with fully transitioning? Do you have plans to start a new blog about that? After reading through what you have here, I'd be interested to hear your perspective on it.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Right on girl! I've come to this realisation myself very recently and I am starting my own trans journey.

    In fact it's only after I decided I was transgendered/transsexual that I found out about autogynephillia (thanks to Life In Neon) and realised that that was what I had ever since I hit puberty

    So yea, good luck!.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Cool, & @ A Hua Li, me too! I never knew this existed, thank you blog writer!

    I also appreciated your cutting down on the b.s. and just putting forward your opinion as a yes/no answer. I agree with someone above who said it was helpful.

    I feel so much more validated than before, maybe I can actually do something about this now...

    ReplyDelete